Rating
The subject matter is innovative, interesting, and creative
Comments
Quality of source usage and supporting evidence
Comments
Quality of argument and/or research methodology
Comments
Accuracy of Content
Comments
Language is clear and paper is well structured
Comments
Overall conclusions are data/support driven
Comments
Overall Recommendation
Comments to Author
If you have any specific comments to offer the author please suggest them here. Please specify page and paragraph number for any specific changes.
Comments on Language, Style, and Structure
Comments on Argument, Content, and Overall Conclusions
Overall Comments